Do I Need a Dramatic Topic for My College Application Essay?

When it comes to writing college application essays, students often think they must focus on a dramatic event in their lives to submit something compelling. On this episode of Just Admit It!, IvyWise counselors Tasha and Victoria explain why choosing a dramatic college essay topic is not necessary and how being authentic and engaging in your essays is more important.

Key Takeaways

• You do not need a dramatic topic to write a compelling college application essay. Authenticity matters far more than your chosen topic.
• Ordinary moments can be powerful. Some of the strongest essays grow out of small, meaningful experiences that reveal values, growth, and perspective.
• You are never obligated to write about hardship or trauma. Even if something difficult has happened to you, you should only write about it if it truly serves your story and you feel comfortable doing so.
• Focus on what the essay reveals about you. Admissions readers care less about the topic itself and more about the insight, reflection, and character it communicates.
• Brainstorm organically before worrying about prompts. Free writing, conversations, and self-reflection often surface better topics than starting with the Common App prompts alone.
• Some students do work well with prompts — and that’s okay. The best approach is the one that helps you tell your story clearly and confidently.
• Beautiful writing isn’t enough on its own. A strong college essay balances clear structure and reflection with engaging prose.
• Clarity beats cleverness. Direct, well-organized essays are often more effective than abstract formats or overly experimental structures.
• You don’t have to say everything in one essay. The personal statement is just one part of the college application — choose an essay topic that feels true, manageable, and meaningful.

Podcast Transcript

Tasha:

Hi there. Welcome to semester 12, episode seven of the IvyWise Just Admit It! podcast, where former deans and directors of admission give expert insight into the complex college admissions landscape.

I’m Tasha, your host. I’m an admissions counselor at IvyWise, a former international admission officer at USC and former assistant director of international admissions at Boston University.

This season on the show: FAQs in college admissions. We’ll be spending each episode focused on a frequently asked question, breaking it down, and answering it thoroughly. Today’s episode: Do I need a dramatic topic for my college application essay?

To help me answer this question is my colleague, Victoria. Hi, Victoria. Could you please introduce yourself?

Victoria:

Hi. Thank you so much for having me on the podcast. My name is Victoria and I am an admissions counselor at IvyWise. Before IvyWise, I worked as an assistant director of admissions at the University of Chicago — which is my alma mater — and Sarah Lawrence College. I’ve also worked as a college counselor in an independent high school for a number of years. So, I’ve seen many different sides of this process.

Tasha:

Great — thank you so much, Victoria.

So, once again, the question is: Do I need a dramatic topic for my college application essay?

I want to start by unpacking the word “dramatic.” I was immediately curious about why that word is being used to describe an essay topic. So, let’s begin by answering the question directly — because it really is a yes-or-no question.

Do you need a dramatic topic for your college application essay? What would you say to that, Victoria?

Victoria:

I would say no. I think that’s one of the biggest misconceptions I see when students — especially juniors — start thinking about what they want to write about and begin drafting their essays. I think it comes from a very understandable idea that you need to stand out in the admissions process.

And so, people often equate standing out with being big, bold, and therefore dramatic. But there are many different ways to stand out in an admissions pool without being dramatic in your personal statement. I think that’s a fine line that needs to be walked.

Tasha:

Absolutely. So, I’m going to go ahead and take a stab at the word “dramatic” here.

To me, drama doesn’t necessarily mean something sad, but more the idea that something really major, unexpected, or life-altering has to happen — and that you then have to write about it in your college essay. I think that’s probably why the word “dramatic” is being used in this FAQ. Students have picked up this idea — from external sources, from their peers, from a lot of different places — that they need drama in their application to be a compelling candidate.

So, I want to start by deconstructing that idea. If you don’t necessarily need a dramatic topic, then what do you need?

Victoria:

Yeah, so I think, like a lot of things in life, dramatic moments stand out to us because they’re out of the ordinary. That’s what we hear about in the news — unexpected events, big moments when something major is happening in someone’s life.

Because those moments get so much attention, we start to internalize the idea that to stand out, something big has to happen to you. But sometimes the most poignant personal statements are the ones that really get at the heart of who you are, and that comes through authenticity and a genuine sense of self.

The traits and values you end up writing about — the things that show who you are as a person — can come from moments that aren’t huge or dramatic at all. For many of us, life isn’t filled with constant big events. You might have an “aha” moment that feels very meaningful to you, but from the outside doesn’t seem all that dramatic. Maybe it happened during a trip to get ice cream, right?

I think people often equate being poignant with being big or unexpected, and those two things don’t actually have to go together. For some students, something major may have happened in their lives — and if that feels right to write about, that’s okay. But what matters most is authenticity, a coherent narrative that makes sense, and an essay that highlights strong character traits and values: openness, a willingness to grow, a desire to learn, and the kind of perspective that makes someone a great addition to a college campus.

By the end of the essay, I want to say, “I really want to read more about this student.” I want to think that that person would be a great roommate or classmate — someone I’d want to take an improv class with, or a philosophy class with, or whatever it might be. And that doesn’t require a dramatic topic.

Feeling like you by the end of the essay — that’s the most important part of this whole process, even though it can be hard to get there.

Tasha:

Absolutely. I want to go back to something you said about whether you’ve had something dramatic happen to you — and the fact that you could choose to write about it, but you don’t necessarily have to.

For a lot of different reasons and circumstances, students may have gone through really difficult experiences, whether that’s loss or some kind of trauma. And they may feel like they’re expected to write about it in their college application simply because it’s the hardest thing that’s happened to them.

I just want to point out that that isn’t necessarily the case. As an admissions counselor, I would never pressure a student to write about something they’re not ready to write about — something that’s too difficult, that they don’t want to share, or that may have impacted them deeply but isn’t part of the story they’re trying to tell through their application.

There are circumstances where writing about a difficult experience can add meaningfully to your profile — if you feel comfortable doing so. But absolutely not if you don’t. So, I think taking this question to the next level means flipping it around: not only do you not need a dramatic topic, but even if you do have something “dramatic” you could write about, you don’t actually have to.

We never want students to feel like they’re required to air out the most painful parts of their lives if they’re not ready or willing to do that.

Victoria:

Yeah, I completely agree. I’ve worked with students who have lost parents, and with students who’ve experienced other significant challenges, like bullying. While those experiences may have deeply affected them, they’re not always the best lens through which to talk about who they are as a whole person.

And that’s something people sometimes forget to ask themselves: Is this topic actually serving me? Is it allowing me to talk about what I value and the qualities that are most inherently me? If it’s not, there are other ways to include those experiences in your application.

For example, you might have a college counselor reference something significant that happened to you. Or you could briefly address it in the additional information section — just a short explanation like, “This happened. I lost a parent a couple of years ago. It affected me academically, but I’ve been resilient since.”

And maybe that’s all you need to say about it. Maybe it doesn’t need to be an entire essay. So, I really encourage students to think about whether they’re choosing a topic because it helps them share who they are and what matters to them — or because it feels like something they should write about. Those are two very different approaches, and the latter isn’t one I would recommend.

Tasha:

That’s such a great question to ask yourself — thank you for that, Victoria.

So where do you recommend students begin when they’re just starting to brainstorm and think about topics for their college essay?

Victoria:

There are a lot of different schools of thought on this, and a lot of different approaches. For me, I tend to take a more organic approach with my students. That usually involves a mix of free-writing exercises — where I give prompts and see what topics naturally surface — and some motivational interviewing, which helps us explore what’s really sitting in their minds and might work as a way for them to talk about themselves.

Between the free writing and those conversations, we’re often able to get to some really compelling college essay topics. What I always remind my students is that the most important part isn’t necessarily the topic itself, but what we learn about you through that topic.

So, I always ask: Does this topic really serve you? Does it give you the space to share your values, your growth, and who you are becoming? If it doesn’t, then we should look for a different one. Students often think the topic itself is what matters most, but what truly matters is what the essay reveals about who you are, how you’ve grown, and how you might show up on a college campus.

There are other students and counselors I know who take a different approach, which is to start by looking at the prompts they’re given. From there, you can think, “Do I want to answer one of these specific questions?”

I tend to shy away from that approach because one of the prompts is essentially a topic of your choice. That creates a lot more room to not feel defined by the prompt itself. That said, some students don’t necessarily connect as easily to the more organic, conversational approach I described earlier.

I haven’t worked with a student yet who needed to rely exclusively on the prompts, but there absolutely could be a student for whom that approach works very well. For them, looking closely at the Common App prompts and deciding which one resonates most can be a helpful way to get started, and then they can build a story they want to tell within those parameters.

Tasha:

Yeah, and I wanted to follow up a bit on something you mentioned — motivational interviewing. Can you say more about what that looks like in practice?

Victoria:

So instead of a more traditional interview style — where I’m just asking a student a list of questions — I make it much more conversational. I’ll often gently push students to talk more about areas I think could work well as a topic.

This is something you can do with a counselor or even a parent — anyone you feel comfortable having an open dialogue with — where they can encourage you to talk more about the things you light up about or the moments that really illustrate who you are.

For example, I might ask a student to write about what they value most, and in their free write they mention spending time with family. On its own, writing generally about spending time with family doesn’t tell me a ton beyond the fact that it’s important to them. So that’s where the follow-up questions come in.

I might ask, “What is it about spending time with your younger sibling that you really enjoy?” Or, “What has that taught you — about responsibility, time management, or patience?” And then we’ll zoom out and ask, “Are there other areas of your life where you use those same skills?”

From there, I’m taking notes and helping the student see patterns. Then we can step back and ask, “Do you think you could write an essay that connects these ideas?” That’s often how a strong, authentic topic starts to come together.

Tasha:

I am definitely going to try that out — that makes a ton of sense. Victoria, thank you for outlining that so clearly and for giving us those examples.

We’ve already talked a bit about the prompts, and as you mentioned, there are quite a few of them. There are seven Common Application personal statement prompts, and the final one is essentially a choose-your-own-topic option — share an essay on any topic of your choice.

Rather than going through all seven prompts here, I’ll just point folks to the Common App itself, or to an article we have in our KnowledgeBase that breaks all of them down.

But I did want to add that I absolutely agree with Victoria. Because the prompts are so open-ended — and because there’s literally a fully open-ended option — I usually don’t start there with my students. Instead, I start from a different place: what from your life could be compelling to write about, and what you want to highlight, share, and make part of your overall narrative — rather than trying to figure out how to fit yourself into one particular question.

So, I just wanted to take a minute to address the prompts and clarify that there are seven of them, they’re quite open-ended, and you can always check out the exact language in our KnowledgeBase if you’re curious.

Knowing that, what other practical tips do you have for students on choosing a college essay topic? Let’s say they’ve done those initial brainstorming exercises and now have two or three options they feel good about — how should they think about narrowing it down?

Victoria:

Yeah, so I think writing a lot — and then having material to work from — is really my preferred method. And the reason for that is that the first essay you write isn’t always the one you end up using. A lot of growth happens throughout high school, and even between junior and senior year.

Students sometimes forget just how intense and fast that growth can be. Something you write in March of junior year might not feel right anymore by the end of the summer, and that’s fine. So, part one is being okay with trying out a few different ideas.

Part two is being really honest with yourself about what feels comfortable to write about. When you did the free writing, which topic did you actually enjoy starting to write? This idea of “I should write about this because it shows leadership” isn’t always the right approach. There are so many other ways to highlight those qualities elsewhere in your application — it doesn’t all have to live in the personal statement.

That’s another thing I remind students of all the time: You don’t need to fit everything into the personal statement. It’s only 650 words. You have other opportunities in the application to share different parts of yourself, and trying to include everything just makes the essay feel overwhelming.

Finally, I encourage students to think about the qualities they really want to illuminate through this process, and which topic gives them the best opportunity to do that. Sometimes more than one topic could work, and in the end, you have to choose the one that feels the most true to you. There is an intuitive element to it.

And as counselors, we’re sometimes there to offer perspective, too. I’ve occasionally said to a student, I’ve read a lot of essays on this topic, and you have another option here that might feel fresher. You don’t need the most dramatic or flashy essay — but choosing a topic that isn’t overly done can definitely be a smart move.

Tasha:

Yes, definitely. I think there are some topics that we’ve all read many, many times. And I also think there is a way to write about those topics in a way that feels truly unique to a student — depending on exactly how it’s approached — so that the topic almost becomes something else entirely.

But what you’re pointing out is that if an essay reads like a very cookie‑cutter version of a topic that admissions readers have seen over and over again, it can start to feel indistinguishable from the student themselves. And I would absolutely agree with that.

So that covers choosing a topic — but then there’s the writing itself, right?

Victoria:

Yeah — so I think another thing I’ve noticed, especially having worked in schools as well, is that some students are assigned personal narratives in English class. And what those assignments often emphasize is creating a beautiful piece of writing — lovely prose, something that flows really well and feels wonderful to read.

From an admissions standpoint, that doesn’t always give us what we need as readers. There’s an important distinction here: A personal narrative is one thing, but the college admissions personal statement is a different kind of personal narrative. Style does matter — and it’s great to have a beautifully written essay — as long as it also contains the substance we need to see.

Where students sometimes get stuck is trying to craft that beautiful essay first and then tacking on a little reflection at the end. Really, that balance should be flipped. You have to remember that admissions readers are reading these essays very quickly — often in one to two minutes. As Tasha mentioned, we get very good at gaining a lot of information and a strong sense of a student in that short amount of time.

So, while beautiful writing is a bonus, what we really need is to understand who you are — at least one meaningful facet of you. It doesn’t have to capture your entire identity in 650 words, but it should highlight something that matters deeply to you: how you’ve grown, how you’ve changed, or how your perspective has developed over time.

All of those can be great entry points for an essay. But if you’re focused only on crafting something elegant, you often lose space for authentic reflection. So, I really encourage students to leave room for that reflection. Start with the not-beautiful essay — almost like a journal entry.

Ask yourself: “Why am I talking about this? Why does it matter to me?” And then write more about that. That’s where motivational interviewing comes in. What about this experience matters to you? What has it taught you about yourself? How has it helped you grow, change, or develop as a person?

When you start leaning into that kind of self‑reflection, that’s when you know you’re onto something. That’s when we get an essay that really feels like you — because that level of reflection, rooted in your own experience, isn’t something anyone else can replicate.

Tasha:

Thank you so much for pointing that out — and for bringing up style and the narrative essay — because I really want to echo what you’re saying here. When I was reading applications over the last ten years or so, it felt like a lot of students were experimenting with different formats in an effort to stand out.

Things like hermit crab essays, where you use a nontraditional format — a recipe, a receipt, something more abstract — to present the information. And while those can be great tools for creative nonfiction or a narrative essay in an English class, I don’t think they’re always the best fit for the college admissions essay.

So, I think some of those more creative, abstract, nontraditional formats aren’t always the best choice for this specific purpose. At some point, there may have been the misconception that the more unique the presentation, the better — but I actually think being more direct is often much more effective.

Making sure your application readers can clearly understand what you’re trying to say about yourself is key. I’m always encouraging students to use strong topic sentences, clear transitions, and solid structural scaffolding between paragraphs.

Because as someone who’s been a reader, I want to feel confident that I understand what the student is trying to communicate without having to slow down and decode it. When an essay gets too abstract, the reader has to work much harder to understand the nuts and bolts of what’s being presented.

So, I just wanted to add that perspective.

Victoria:

Yeah, I completely agree. And I think that goes back to your point about how quickly admissions readers are moving through these essays. They’ve read thousands of them, and it’s very likely they’ve seen a topic similar to yours before.

That’s why it’s so important that the essay isn’t just focused on beautiful prose or an abstract format. What really makes it stand out is when it feels unmistakably you —and that comes from your perspective, your reflection, and your way of thinking about the experience.

Tasha:

Victoria, I think we’ve come to the end of this episode.

Thank you so much again for coming on the Just Admit It! podcast.

Victoria:

Thank you so much for having me.

Tasha:

And that just about wraps up this episode of The Just Admit It! podcast. If you have any suggestions about what we should be covering, please email us at [email protected]. In the meantime, you can catch up on all our previous episodes by visiting our podcast page and be sure to bookmark our KnowledgeBase for additional help with navigating the complex and competitive admissions process.

At IvyWise, we bring together a team of former deans and directors of admission at top universities to give students, parents, and fellow educators the most up-to-date, higher ed news and practical admissions advice. Our experts help students navigate everything from college applications and K-8 planning to graduate school admissions in standardized testing.

Visit ivywise.com today to embark on your journey to your best fit schools with the world’s leading educational consultancy. From IvyWise, I’m your host, Tasha, and this has been Just Admit It! See you next time.

Learn More

Editor’s Note: This transcript has been cleaned up and edited for clarity and readability.